“The more that you read, the more things you will know. The more that you learn, the more places you’ll go.”
– Dr Seuss
Lies We Tell Ourselves
Author: Robin Talley
Published: 30th September 2014
Goodreads Rating: 4.06 out of 5
Reviewed: September 2014
Lies We Tell Ourselves by Robin Talley is a realistic tale about the beginning of the integration of coloured people into white schools in late 1950s America. In Virginia, it is 1959 and ten Negros are beginning their first day at Jefferson Highschool. The experience is narrated by one of the ten: Sarah. In other parts of the novel, the voice changes to that of Linda, a particularly nasty white girl, one of countless students opposed to integration.
Although many people are taught about the Black civil rights movement, it is still shocking to read about the horrible things they had to endure. By writing in the first person, Talley encourages the reader to try to understand how they would feel in a similar situation. Sarah and her friends instantly become the victims of verbal and physical abuse, to which members of authority turn a blind eye.
To Sarah, Linda is a nasty spoilt bully who, although she does not join in with the taunting and abuse, is as bad as the rest of them. Through reading Linda’s account, it becomes clear that her behaviour has a lot to do with her home life, particularly her father’s attitude. After being forced to partner with Sarah for a French project, Linda begins to question why there is so much emphasis on skin colour. Yet, not wanting to be shunned by her friends, she keeps these thoughts to herself.
Sarah is also struggling to come to terms with her sexual preference for girls. It has been drilled into her that these thoughts are a sin. She hides her true feelings from everyone and constantly berates herself mentally for being “unnatural”. But it turns out she may not be the only one with these thoughts.
The lies referred to in the title are not the blatant or harmful lies but rather the lies the characters believe or even want to believe. Each chapter begins with a lie that reflects what is occurring in the novel at that time; for example, “There’s no need to be afraid” and “I don’t care what they think of me.” This is an interesting way of telling the story as it emphasizes Sarah’s determination to keep going despite what she is subjected to. It also reveals the mental struggles she faces. The lies also disclose Linda’s conflicting feelings towards the segregation laws.
Although not a religious novel, each part begins with the title of a Christian hymn. It was the norm for everyone to attend church, and despite the separate churches, it was something both black and white people did. Sarah and Linda have faith in God, yet both use the bible’s teachings for opposing arguments. The religious aspect also highlights Sarah’s self-hatred and belief that she has fallen into sin.
Unfortunately, in today’s world, there are still issues with racism and homophobia, but after reading Lies We Tell Ourselves, it is evident that these situations have vastly improved since the 1950s, at least in the Western world. Without children such as Sarah going through these horrible experiences, the situation would never have changed. There would still be separate schools, slavery and inaccurate opinions about race inequality. America has a lot to thank these brave students for, who were the first to create mixed-race schools.
Overall this is a brilliant book. Well-written and realistic, it draws the reader into the characters’ stories. Although Lies We Tell Ourselves is a work of fiction, it is historically accurate and can teach a lot about America’s history to young adults today.
Black Ice
Author: Becca Fitzpatrick
Published: 7th October 2014
Goodreads Rating: 3.87 out of 5
Reviewed: September 2014 (pre-published copy)
The author of the Hush, Hush saga, Becca Fitzpatrick, steps away from the paranormal genre with this new contemporary thriller, Black Ice. Britt Pfeiffer has persuaded her best friend, Korbie, to go on an adventurous backpacking trip in the Teton mountains for their senior spring break. It immediately gets off to a bad start when the girls get caught in a freak snowstorm and stranded a long way from their lodge. Luckily, they come across a cabin owned by a guy named Shaun, who is there with his friend Mason. But it may not be the haven they hoped it to be. With her best friend’s life in danger as well as her own, Britt has to remain strong to save them; either that or hope that her ex-boyfriend will realize they are missing and rescue them.
Initially, it is difficult to connect with Britt, who narrates the entire story. She, as well as Korbie, is a rather annoying, spoilt daddy’s girl. It first appears the novel is about two whining teenagers, both used to getting their own ways, fending for themselves in the mountains. Once the girls face a life-or-death situation, Britt’s character develops rapidly. She becomes more independent, clever and likeable, which makes the story a lot easier to read and enjoy.
Black Ice is a thriller containing a murder mystery, which links all the characters together but in ways that you would not originally expect. It is also a romance novel. Although Mason is perceived as a bad guy, Britt falls for him, sparking a risky relationship.
Despite the shaky start, Fitzpatrick’s latest novel is full of exciting twists and turns. It is exhilarating to try and work out who is good, who is bad, and who has been murdering girls in the mountains.
Tin Lily
Author: Joann Swanson
Published: 6th July 2014
Goodreads Rating: 4.05 out of 5
Reviewed: October 2014
Joann Swanson’s debut novel Tin Lily is a beautifully written story about a teenage girl’s struggle to deal with the murder of her mother by her alcoholic father. Lily Berkenshire narrowly misses being killed herself when her father runs out of bullets. While the police are out looking for him, Lily moves to Seattle to live with her Aunt Margie. With the help of a therapist, Lily battles to deal with triggering memories and the dissociative spells that follow. There begin to be small improvements in her condition – making a new friend, getting a pet cat – yet, her father is out there somewhere, meaning she is still in danger.
Lily’s first-person narrative emphasizes the mental struggle she is undergoing. Short sentences and the quick topic changes reveal how hard it is for Lily to remain focused on the here and now rather than retreat into the silence of a dissociative period. Those with experiences of mental health problems will understand the confusion Lily feels as she tries to come to terms with the sudden events that have changed her life forever.
One particularly striking thing about Swanson’s writing is her use of metaphors, specifically the one used within the title. The words Tin Lily only begin to make sense as the novel progresses. Lily originally describes herself as tin: plain and hollow with no emotion left inside. A short speech from her aunt gives an alternative metaphor for tin, which is intensely thought-provoking: “Tin isn’t very interesting just flat. It’s got a lot more character when it’s been stressed and moulded. The only way to do that is to bend it until it cries.” Aunt Margie, a metallurgist, is referring to the way tin is adapted to create other, sometimes beautiful, objects. Swanson is showing that although a person may go through terrible times and feel broken inside, they can become a different person in a good way, see things in new ways, become more empathetic etc. It is a powerful message for the readers to take away from this book.
There were times when it felt like the story could be drawn out or go in different directions. For example, Swanson introduces a spoiled rich girl who lives in the building where Lily’s therapist works. Lily bumps into her twice and feels uncomfortable and unworthy, but after that, there is no more reference to that girl. For a moment, it seemed the narrative would introduce a bullying theme, but nothing happened.
Overall, Tin Lily is a moving novel containing serious themes. Although intended for young adults, it may not be suitable for some teens who are either very fragile-minded or unable to grasp the gravity of Lily’s situation.
The Daughter of the Sea and the Sky
Author: David Litwack
Published: 12th April 2014
Goodreads Rating: 3.62 out of 5
Reviewed: October 2014
The Daughter of the Sea and the Sky by David Litwack is set in a world ravaged by religious wars. The people have separated themselves into believers and non-believers. Helena Brewster and Jason Adams live in the Republic, where the people rely heavily on reason and reject the supposedly irrational ramblings of the zealots who live on the “Blessed Lands”. One day, a nine-year-old girl, Kailani, escapes from the Blessed Land and sails to the Republic, where Helena and Jason find her. Kailani is immediately captured and questioned by the authorities, who want to send her to a correctional facility to undo the brainwashing of the zealots.
Since it is several months until her tribunal, Helena and Jason become Kailani’s legal guardians and take her to live at Glen Eagle Farm, away from the main population of the busy towns. Kailani is loved and admired by the inhabitants of the farm, but people on the Blessed Land want her back.
It is an interesting story that explores a range of themes. For Helena, there is the grief she is suffering as a result of the recent death of her father and the feelings she has towards her mother, by whom she felt abandoned. Between Jason and Helena, a romance develops as the two connect in their determination to protect Kailani. The most important theme, however, is the antagonism between believers and non-believers. Those living in the Blessed Land want to indoctrinate everybody with their ideals about the soul, whereas in the Republic, this is forbidden, as they insist on living a life ruled through fact. As the story goes on, certain characters begin to understand the need for both realism and religion. One person even suggests, “In our pursuit of reason, we’ve become as unreasonable as the other side.”
Kailani is a lovable character, which makes the novel a joy to read. It is interesting to compare how a child raised under a strict religion innocently views the world, in comparison with adults who have no faith whatsoever. Although written for adults, it is suitable for young teens to read too, who although they may not understand the significance of the two different sides, are sure to love and enjoy reading about Kailani.
Capturing Jasmina
Author: Kimberly Rae
Published: 1st March 2014
Goodreads Rating: 4.07 out of 5
Reviewed: October 2014
Kimberly Rae draws attention to the ongoing trafficking of children in India in her young adult novel Capturing Jasmina. Jasmina was only ten when her father sold her and her brother Samir to a man promising safety and good education. In reality, the siblings end up in a sweatshop slaving over clothes to be sold in America. After three years, they escape, only to be trafficked a second time. Eventually, Jasmina and Samir are separated, and Jasmina becomes a street kid.
Whilst living on the streets, Jasmina encounters a Christian missionary, Asha, rescuing women from brothels by either offering them a safe place to live, or at the very least, spiritually, by teaching them about God and Jesus. Intrigued, Jasmina follows Asha, who offers to help her, too. After having her childhood robbed from her, it seems like Jasmina, with the help of those who trust in God, will get back on her feet again.
Despite being a short novel, Rae paints a contrasting image of the Western world. Jasmina finds the concept of a simple toilet baffling. It is not until you hear or see what is happening to innocent people in other parts of the world that you realize there are many things you take for granted.
Capturing Jasmina emphasizes how difficult it is to escape once trafficked. In these situations, people belong to everyone but themselves. They have no freedom, and running away can cause more problems than it solves. The novel also shows what Christians can do to help. Although no one can completely solve the situation, the tiniest piece of aid they can provide is a step in the right direction.
It is slightly disappointing that we do not find out what happened to Samir once he was separated from his sister. Jasmina’s first-person narrative makes it clear that what she wants most is to be reunited with her family. In a way, although there is a positive ending, not finding her brother makes it clear that there cannot always be happy endings. It is not possible to save everyone.
Written from a young teenager’s point of view makes this book suitable for readers aged twelve and older. Christians will appreciate the biblical references, yet there is not too much religious jargon for non-believers or those of other religions to get offended.
If you would like to support my blog, become a Patreon from £5p/m or “buy me a coffee” for £3. Thank You!